stats for wordpress
 







Are you on Facebook?

Would you please click "like" in the box to your right, or

Visit us on Facebook!


Comment: Harold Ford’s Treatment No Better Than Tea Party Protests

by David Badash on February 25, 2010

in Civil Rights,Marriage,Politics

Harold Ford’s reception tonight at New York City’s LGBT Center, which hosted the Stonewall Democrats’ event at which Ford was invited to speak about his stance on issues affecting the LGBTQ community, was little short of a mob scene. Protesters, organized by “The Power,” an LGBTQ advocacy group that has worked tirelessly — albeit with tactics at times well-intentioned yet ill-advised –  to further the civil rights cause for all LGBTQ Americans, turned this event into Tea Party style politics.

Protesters brandished bold signs labeling Ford, “Liar,” “Anti-gay Liar,” and “Snakeoil Harold.” But it wasn’t their brandishing of signs, it was their bellicose voices, shouting, interrupting — all of which were criticized by the Stonewall Democrats leadership, to no avail. At every opportunity, protesters shouted down Ford, who clearly wasn’t capable of withstanding the half-hour verbal abuse in a hot, stuffy, small meeting room.

It was demeaning and disrespectful to Mr. Ford, it was demeaning and disrespectful to the Stonewall Democrats, it was demeaning and disrespectful to the LGBTQ community, and worse of all, it was demeaning and disrespectful to our national political debate.

One could argue that Ford’s stance and “flip-flopping” on gay rights are just as demeaning, and to that I would agree.

Make no mistake. I am fully on record as being adamantly opposed to Harold Ford, period, whether he chooses to run for New York’s U.S. Senate seat, or for any other office. I’ve written close to a dozen pieces against him. And his poor performance and clear lack of understanding of basic issues tonight merely proves my point.

Ford is bad for New York. Not because of his poor understanding of LGBTQ issues, but because of his poor understanding of all the issues, including his poor understanding of his own record — which is, needless to say, also poor.

However, the man was a guest in our home, and he was treated as a despot, a tyrant to be overthrown and burned at the stake. There was no way Ford was intellectually capable of changing any heart or mind in that room — even before he arrived. His poor commentary made that clear from the outset. His lack of preparation merely reinforced the obvious fact that he’s not capable of serving the people of the state of New York. The protesters should have merely given him the opportunity to speak, knowing he would do himself more damage than they ever could.

Ford, if anything, may have gained slight political advantage tonight, if only by garnering the sympathy of the less-informed and the anti-gay voting bloc. They, too, won’t believe he’s changed. They’ll see he’s no “fierce advocate,” and they already know Gillibrand is. And they’ll see how he was treated and actually feel sorry for him.

Michael Crawford, who was instrumental in helping Washington, D.C. gain marriage equality, tonight wrote,

“The shouting down of Harold Ford is another example of gays acting out rather than acting smart.”

I agree.

Even Queerty, itself famous for poor manners, had this to say,

“The event wasn’t just unfriendly to Ford; it was rude.

So, allow us to take a moment to address that: Shouting over the invited guest? Demanding he “go home,” when you’re the ones who bothered showing up to an event you knew he’d appear at? If you want to protest him, fine, but at least let him speak. We’d expect the same for our own. This was uncalled for and makes New York’s gay community look intolerant and juvenile — the same things we accuse others of being.”

The only ones who looked worse than Ford tonight were the members of the unruly, angry, rude, nasty mob that interrupted Ford’s speech with cries reminiscent of Joe Wilson’s “You lie!,” followed by, “You’re a liar,” “Go back home to Tennessee!” and “Anti-choice! Anti-gay! Snake Oil Harry, go away!”

Seriously. Joe Wilson, Dick Armey, Newt Gingrich, and Sarah Palin would have been proud tonight. Michelle Malkin, especially, I’m sure is thrilled. Another “Gay marriage mob” story for her pen to twist.

But I, for one, am not proud.

This “protest” wasn’t “civil disobedience.” There was nothing civil about it at all.

I’ve spent the past year and a half working twelve to eighteen hour days, sometimes seven days a week, trying to educate, communicate, and illustrate why equality for the LGBTQ community is the right thing for America. I’ve immersed myself and invested my life in this movement. No one can say I’m anything if not a dedicated activist to this movement and a tireless supporter of LGBTQ rights and of our community.

But I do not support the ranting and raving tactics and tantrums of an angry mob who put their anger and, yes, their hatred, above the larger picture of public perception and optics, and civil discourse and debate.

Wrestle Ford on the facts, in a civil debate, and we gain the upper hand. Wrestle him to the ground, and we look like schoolyard bullies.

Ironically, today in a piece I wrote for Bilerico, I said,

“There are many roads to reach our success. I will not fight anyone for trying. I will for not.”

While I won’t fight these protesters, I will voice my opinion.

Tonight, these protesters made us look bad and Harold Ford look, well, better than he deserved to. Tonight, these protesters hurt our efforts. Tonight, I, for one, was embarrassed.

When we’ve sunk to the level of those we despise, like the Tea Partiers who disrupted the health care debates all summer, or like Congressman Wilson’s “You lie!” outburst during President Obama’s joint session of Congress, when we’ve sunk so low that we emulate their tactics, we’ve lost the upper hand, our integrity, the support of the public, and we’ve given the opposition a win.

Next time, folks, let’s be the bigger party. Not the Tea Party.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Friends:

We invite you to sign up for our new mailing list, and subscribe to The New Civil Rights Movement via email or RSS.

Also, please like us on Facebook, and follow us on Twitter!

{ 16 comments }

Chris February 25, 2010 at 7:17 am

BULLSHIT. In 2006, the man voted to forcibly divorce gay couples already married. Did that not occur to him? (How about we vote on an ammendment that reverses Loving v VA now, and dissolve Mr. Ford's marriage? What would his reaction be to that?)

Let me reiterate this — he voted to allow the Federal Gov't come into your hom and dissolve your marriage and take any legal standing away from you and your partner.

How is there a polite response to that kind of attack? It reminds me of the Act Up days — there is no politeness when your home and life are on the line.

If Ford is serious in his newfound support, let him do the work like any politician in NY would have to. After 5 or 10 years of significant support, maybe he can redeem himself, but I doubt it, and I certainly don't think that kind of work interests him very much.

fradiavolo February 25, 2010 at 11:40 am

Absolutely agree! The protesters merely treated Ford with the same contempt that he has shown towards us. Respect goes both ways — it's not a game of solitaire.

ewe February 28, 2010 at 1:29 am

Touche'. Tell it like it is Chris.

BGryphon February 25, 2010 at 1:36 pm

I agree that civil discourse is generally the preferred method when engaging those who disagree. But as our President has learned, there comes a time when one (WE) must stand up, call out the lies of our enemies, and refuse to 'take it' any more.

Now that a Democratic administration with Dem-controlled Houses of Congress won't take us, and our rights, seriously the time for civil discourse is drawing to a close.

Sportin' Life February 25, 2010 at 2:17 pm

God save us from hand-wringers who think etiquette is more important than morality.

Isebrand February 25, 2010 at 3:43 pm

Tea Baggers disrupted Congress Member's public forums with lies based on fear. LGBT protestors disrupted the Stonewall NYC's event with evidence of and based on *Ford's own record.* A politician supporting potential health care reform isn't a situation of abject immorality; conversely, Ford campaigning and voting against justice and equality for LGBT Americans was highly immoral in the minds of many progressives regardless of their Party affiliation, if any, or their sexual orientation. Frankly, Ford's paid no price politically for his pernicious assaults on LGBT Americans…until now. I actually think that the event was a win-win for Ford and the LGBT protesters. The objective truth is that they BOTH got their messages (via the press' subsequent coverage of the event), whether one agrees or disagrees with the messages or the modes of there delivery.

Justin February 25, 2010 at 5:31 pm

If the Protesters had not been there, then the media would not have picked it up as a story or some New Yorkers would have not been aware of his record or the disdain the LGBT community has for him. The fact that we are talking about this today and his record, shows the protests worked. It made it on NY1 last night and in that alot of Straight, Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender New Yorkers saw and heard about his record. That is a win, thanks to the loud protests ;-)

The fact is that the protests educated people in that they were good. When someone is discriminatory toward my family, I am not going to use etiquette and I am going to speak up so people hear and know. In todays world of busy schedules and distractions in our lives, that many times means we have to speak loud to drown out the other side and to educate. If there are people that feel uncomfortable standing up to bigots with their voice loudly then that is fine. But don't put down those of us that are willing to speak loudly and educate people on our issues. I think some people need to take a look at where their comfort zones are and how far are they willing to speak out against bigots.

Cody D. February 25, 2010 at 6:07 pm

My boyfriend and I have argued about this issue. I understand the impulse to yell and scream and shout, but I'm with David on this one.

First, Let's be honest with ourselves. No one who opposes equality measures for the LGBT community looks at a screaming gay protest and thinks, "Oh, yes. I understand what they're saying. I'm educated now on gay issues." The reality is more like this, "Look at that screaming mob of fags. See? They're exactly what we think they are." (And I'm not from a comfortable gay place like New York. I'm in the deep south. I know from anti-gay bigotry.)

Secondly, you can't point an accusing finger at the crazy ranty tea bag crowd and turn around and behave exactly like the crazy ranty Tea bag crowd. The behavior is either justifiable or not. We're either people of principle or we're not.

And might I suggest this: what should tick you off, more than anything else, is that we're still a community that eats its own. We're not above behaving badly. We're not above criticism. But we certainly behave as though anything done in the name of gay rights is valid and worth doing. That's simply not so. Listen to criticism, especially when it comes from someone like David who does more than most to further the cause of equality. It's easy to be a keyboard revolutionary (to borrow a phrase from James Withers at 365gay.com). Before you sling insults at David and others who criticize elements of the movement, assess what you've done for the cause. If you're doing less, be respectful to those doing more.

Geo Vaughn February 25, 2010 at 6:12 pm

David, it's individuals like you that make us look weak, and afraid… The reason we've been walked on for generations, the reason our progress has come just a drop at a time. You may not be proud of what those protesters did last night, but I AM.

African Americans didn't get to where they are today by "debating", or writing articles, (or in blogs). They protested, demanded, intimidated, and forcefully took their freedom.

If you are too comfortable sitting on your ass while the people you voted into office strip you of every birth right; then you go right ahead do that… But don't shit all over those who are standing up loud, and taking the heat FOR YOU.

While you sit there behind your little laptop, thinking of the next tired thing to say about this new revolution of LGBT activists, know this: WE WILL NO LONGER TOLERATE THOSE WHO COMMIT ACTS AGAINST OUR FREEDOM!

If you think last night was "rude", you better tighten up your rainbow belt, because that was just the tip of the iceberg.

David Badash February 25, 2010 at 6:58 pm

@Geo Vaughn

Nice. Just what we need right now. Ad hominen attacks. Keep it up, and we'll have become our enemies. Are you proud of that?

Trust me, there are far more who agree with me than with your position.

Geo Vaughn February 25, 2010 at 7:26 pm

"Trust me, there are far more who agree with me than with your position." David, there are also FAR MORE who agree we should be at night clubs instead of advocating for LGBT rights, there are also FAR MORE who agree that we should be treated as second class citizens. Therefore, your argument is weak and irrelevant.

We are NOT becoming our enemies, however we've come to learn that sometimes it's necessary to fight them with some of their own ammo. If Lt. Dan Choi were to show up to one of their meetings, or churches, they would have SHUT HIS SPEECH DOWN.

David Badash February 25, 2010 at 7:01 pm

This isn't about comfort zones, though I agree I am uncomfortable with inappropriate, rude, angry protests. This is about the bigger picture.

(By the way, had the protest been OUTSIDE the meeting, i totally would have supported that. THAT would have been fine. THAT would have been appropriate. But you don't invite someone to speak and then not let them. That's what the Tea party does. is that who we want to become?)

The protesters made the LGBTQ community look like an unhinged mob. And I totally disagree that the protests brought the media. Harold Ford's mere presence brought the media.

I am a fierce advocate for our community. I am also a fierce advocate for equality and fairness. And being smart. This wasn't smart. This didn't help us with public perception. Maybe it got a message to Harold Ford, but one he already knew. It, however, got a message to America, giving the perception that all but gives credence to the bull that people like Michelle Malkin and NOM and the Family Research Council, and the American Family Association spout, that we're "violent activists."

Speaking truth to power works when we speak our truth honorably. That's how we win.

I think Dan Choi is the perfect example of that.

Justin February 26, 2010 at 2:17 am

Actually David I was at the center and Dan Choi did not say anything against the protest. He actually had a sign himself. He also thought our protest at the Marriage Bureau a couple of weeks ago made a difference. So you are a minority with this opinion and it is your uncomfortability.

David if your uncomfortable with these type of protests then I guess you would not have supported Act-Up either (their loud in your face protests) and the valuable work they did on the AIDS crisis. I hope in the future you can come around to seeing the usefulness of these.

a. mcewen February 25, 2010 at 5:16 pm

You don't put your point across by shouting. If anything, your point can be lost by the way you chose to advance it. It's all about intelligent disagreement. Did what happened to Ford bring attention to his hypocrisies or make him seem like the victim of allegedly pushy and radical gays? You answer the question.

There seems to be a point forgotten that with truth comes dignity. If you have the truth on your side, you never need to stoop to the level of the shouters.

Jason_M February 26, 2010 at 7:34 am

Well said, David. Justin above makes an inappropriate and unfair analogy to Act-Up protests. I really don't like the pressures toward conformity of thought in certain gay political circles. Group-think is, btw, what the right accuses the left of.

ewe February 28, 2010 at 1:10 am

You are quite mistaken. He was not a guest in our home. He was a guest of Stonewall Democrats that rent space at the LGBT Community Center. Ford is known to say one thing and do the opposite. Get over it. Those that don't spend their days typing away on a keyboard have the right to voice their objection. He is a liar. No more passivity. You should be ashamed for trying to invoke yourself and those that think like you as the movers and shakers that change anything for the better in and for the gay community. There never would have been a Stonewall if people listened to your advice.

Comments on this entry are closed.

{ 5 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: